Our Menu
Pancakes
Full stack served with choice of 1 side. Gluten free $3.95. 100% Real Maple Syrup $2.50. Add fresh blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, bananas, chocolate chips, or walnuts $1.50 each.
Buttermilk's Own Signature Pancakes
$8.95/Short stack
$12.95/Full stack
Banana and Bacon
$10.95/Short stack
$14.95/Full stack
Slice bananas, crispy crumbled bacon, peanut butter sauce, chocolate whipped cream.
Apple Pie Pancakes
$10.95/Short stack
$14.95/Full stack
Cinnamon sugar-baked apples cooked right in. Topped with cinnamon crumble - sweet vanilla drizzle
Stuffed Pancake
$10.95/Short stack
$14.95/Full stack
Our signature buttermilk pancakes with a gooey center. Choose from Nutella or peanut butter
Cinnaroll Pancakes
$10.95/Short stack
$14.95/Full stack
Brown sugar cinnamon, sweet cream cheese swirl.
Samoa Pancakes
$10.95/Short stack
$14.95/Full stack
Inspired by the Girl Scout Cookies! Coconut-flavored batter, toasted coconut flakes, chocolate chips topped with gooey caramel sauce, chocolate syrup, fresh whipped cream
The Cupcake
$10.95/Short stack
$14.95/Full stack
Rainbow sprinkles, sweet vanilla drizzle, fresh whipped cream.
French Toast
Served with choice of 1 side. Gluten free $3.95. 100% Real Maple Syrup $2.50. Add fresh blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, bananas, chocolate chips, or walnuts $1.50 each.
The Classic
$12.95
Our Award Winning French Toast! Cinnamon brioche bread infused with vanilla egg batter.
S'Mores
$15.95
Fluff and chocolate chips sandwiched between two pieces of our classic French toast. Topped with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate whipped cream, toasted marshmallow, and drizzled with chocolate.
BPF Tower
$14.95
Our classic French toast sandwiched with banana, peanut butter, fluff
The HOLY Cannoli
$15.95
Cannoli cream stuffed between two pieces of our classic French toast. Drizzled with chocolate, topped with chocolate whipped cream and crumbled cannoli shells
French Toast Bites
$12.95
Crunchy fried French toast pieces coated in cinnamon sugar, topped with sweet vanilla drizzle.
Bananas Foster
$15.95
Our classic French toast topped with bananas flambeed in caramel sauce, topped with gooey caramel, fresh whipped cream and cinnamon.
Eggs*
Farm fresh eggs served with choice of toast or a homemade buttermilk biscuit
Gluten free toast $3.95, Egg whites $2.00
Any Way You Want 'Em*
$12.95
Two eggs cooked to your liking served with 2 sides.
Farmhouse*
$15.95
Two eggs cooked to your liking served with bacon, sausage, ham, and choice of 1 side.
Not That Kinda Hash*
$17.95
Buttermilk's savory homemade corned beef hash served with two eggs cooked to your liking and choice of 1 side.
Omelettes
Served with choice of 1 side and your choice of toast or a buttermilk biscuit
Gluten-free toast $3.95
The Fun-Guy
$15.50
Sauteed mushrooms, fresh spinach, crispy crumbled bacon, and tangy goat cheese
The Hercules
$15.50
Fresh spinach, feta cheese, freshly diced tomatoes, scallions, and a hint of oregano.
The Flamethrower
$16.95
Spicy sriracha marinated chicken, crumbled bleu cheese, and scallions
The Florentine
$15.95
Turkey, spinach, sun-dried tomato, caramelized onions, and Swiss cheese
The Butcher Block
$18.95
Juicy sliced steak cooked to your liking, caramelized onions, and white cheddar cheese
Create Your Own Omelette
$13.95
3 egg omelette with your choice of three toppings. Choose from: sauteed mushrooms, sauteed peppers, spinach, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, diced tomato, sun-dried tomato, scallions, jalapenos, ham, turkey, sausage, bacon, American cheese, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, Swiss, pepper jack, fresh mozzarella, feta, goat cheese, mascarpone, bleu cheese crumbles, brie
Extra toppings $1.50 each
Add avocado $3.95, sriracha or grilled chicken $6.00, steak $8.00, shrimp $9.00
Extra toppings $1.50 each
Add avocado $3.95, sriracha or grilled chicken $6.00, steak $8.00, shrimp $9.00
Breakfast Burritos
Choice of white or whole wheat wrap. Served with choice of 1 side.
Southwest Burrito
$16.50
Scrambled eggs, diced ham, peppers, caramelized onions, salsa, Monterey Jack and cheddar cheese, and fresh sliced avocado
The Morning Jogger Burrito
$17.50
Scrambled eggs whites, turkey, Swiss, baby spinach, mushrooms, and diced tomatoes
The Iron Man Burrito
$15.50
Scrambled eggs, hash browns, bacon, sausage, and American cheese
Waffles
Served with choice of 1 side. 100% Real Maple Syrup $2.50. Add fresh blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, bananas, chocolate chips, or walnuts $1.50 each.
Classic
$12.95
Crisp and fluffy Belgian waffle served with whipped butter or homemade sweet cinnamon butter.
The Very Berry Belgian Waffle
$15.95
Our classic Belgian waffle topped with fresh strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, and our homemade fresh whipped cream
The Bella Nutella
$15.95
Nutella drizzle, sliced bananas, and fresh raspberries
Sweet Potato Waffle
$13.95
Served with candied walnuts and our homemade sweet cinnamon butter
A Little Something More
The Traitor*
$15.95
Our spin on the classic eggs benny. Two poached eggs served on homemade buttermilk biscuits with grilled ham and homemade hollandaise served with choice of 1 side.
The Gump Benedict*
$18.95
Open-faced croissant with our cajun shrimp, two poached eggs, homemade hollandaise, and choice of 1 side.
Egg in the Hole*
$14.95
Two pieces of sourdough bread with an over easy egg nestled inside each. Served with choice of 2 sides
Add cheese $1.50
Add cheese $1.50
The 'Ol Barnyard*
$15.95
Two homemade buttermilk biscuits with our house recipe savory white sausage gravy. Served with two eggs any style and choice of 1 side.
Steak & Eggs*
$21.95
Steak cooked to your liking with two eggs any style and toast or a biscuit. Choice of 1 side.
Shrimp & Grits
$18.95
Cajun shrimp set atop creamy cheese grits with cajun cream sauce and scallions.
Chicken & Waffles
$17.95
Our classic Belgian waffle served with Buttermilk's Signature crispy fried chicken (boneless). Topped with maple drizzle.
Sides
For entrees that are served with a choice of side item(s), choose from the following or upgrade to a Premium Side for an additional charge.
2 strips of bacon
2 strips of turkey bacon
2 sausage links
2 slices of ham
Hashbrowns
French fries
Chef's choice cold salad
Cup of cheesy grits
$2.50
Cup of tomato soup
$2.50
Cup of soup du jour
$2.50
Mixed green salad
$2.95
Sweet potato fries
$2.50
Shoestring fried onions
$2.50
Corned beef hash
$4.95
Fresh fruit cup
$2.95
Grilled or sautéed vegetables
$2.50
Sandwiches or Wraps
Served on your choice of bread or wrap with choice of 1 side. Gluten free bread $3.95
Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich
$17.95
Buttermilk's signature fried chicken strips, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, Buttermilk's homemade ranch.
Roma
$17.95
Grilled chicken, spinach, roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomato, fresh mozzarella, garlic aioli
Avocado Toast
$14.95
Toasted multigrain bread served open-faced and topped with sliced avocado, homemade pico de Gallo, chopped bacon. Choice of EVOO or chipotle mayo drizzle.
The Southern Cuban
$17.95
BBQ pulled pork, sliced ham, Swiss, horseradish pickles, and spicy brown mustard.
Tuna Salad
$15.95
Buttermilk tuna salad with crisp bacon, avocado, and lettuce
BLT
$14.95
Bacon, fresh sliced tomato, and lettuce
NYC Reuben
$17.95
Classic Reuben sandwich, pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss, thousand island dressing
Open Faced Steak Sammy*
$18.95
Juicy sliced steak cooked to your liking, sautéed onions, sautéed mushrooms, white cheddar, garlic aioli. Served open-faced.
Buffalo Bleu
$15.95
Cheddar cheese, grilled chicken, homemade chunky bleu cheese, dressing with a drizzle of buffalo sauce. Served on sourdough
Create Your Own Burger
$14.95
Homemade 8oz fresh beef patty served with lettuce, tomato, and red onion. Choose your toppings
Cheese $1.50 each: American, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, feta, goat cheese, fresh mozzarella, Swiss, mascarpone, bleu cheese crumbles, brie, pepper jack
Toppings $1.50 each: fried shoestring onions, sauteed mushrooms, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, sauteed peppers, sun-dried tomato, horseradish pickles, jalapenos, sauerkraut
Add avocado $3.95, bacon $3.00
Cheese $1.50 each: American, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, feta, goat cheese, fresh mozzarella, Swiss, mascarpone, bleu cheese crumbles, brie, pepper jack
Toppings $1.50 each: fried shoestring onions, sauteed mushrooms, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, sauteed peppers, sun-dried tomato, horseradish pickles, jalapenos, sauerkraut
Add avocado $3.95, bacon $3.00
Grilled Cheese
Served with your choice of 1 side.
The Lumberjack
$16.95
Bacon, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, avocado, and sliced tomato served on multigrain bread
Fancy Pig
$17.95
Mascarpone, goat cheese, fig jam, sauteed onions, and BBQ pulled pork served on brioche bread with cinnamon butter
Sweet Brie
$15.95
Brie, grilled pears, ham, and maple mayo served on brioche bread with cinnamon butter
Caprese
$15.95
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, roasted red peppers, spinach, garlic aioli, and balsamic glaze served on ciabatta
The Kitchen Sink
$15.95
Yellow and white cheddar, pepper jack, and goat cheese served on parmesan-crusted sourdough
The "OG"
$14.95
American cheese, bacon, and tomato served on hearty white
Create Your Own
$11.95
Step 1: Choose your bread: hearty white, whole wheat, sourdough, brioche, marble rye, ciabatta, multigrain, gluten-free $3.95
Step 2: Choose three toppings: tomato, red onion, spinach, fried shoestring onions, sauteed mushrooms, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, sauteed peppers, sun-dried tomato, jalapenos, American, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, Swiss, pepper jack, fresh mozzarella, feta, goat cheese, mascarpone, bleu cheese crumbles, brie
Step 3: Add ons - Grilled Chicken $6.00, Sriracha Chicken $6.00, Ham $6.00, Turkey $6.00, or Pastrami $6.00, *Sliced Steak $8.00, Cajun Shrimp $9.00, Avocado $3.95, Bacon $3.00, Horseradish Pickles $1.50
Step 2: Choose three toppings: tomato, red onion, spinach, fried shoestring onions, sauteed mushrooms, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, sauteed peppers, sun-dried tomato, jalapenos, American, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, Swiss, pepper jack, fresh mozzarella, feta, goat cheese, mascarpone, bleu cheese crumbles, brie
Step 3: Add ons - Grilled Chicken $6.00, Sriracha Chicken $6.00, Ham $6.00, Turkey $6.00, or Pastrami $6.00, *Sliced Steak $8.00, Cajun Shrimp $9.00, Avocado $3.95, Bacon $3.00, Horseradish Pickles $1.50
Salads
Add Grilled Chicken $6.00, Sliced Steak $8.00, Cajun Shrimp $9.00
Dressings: Raspberry Vinaigrette, Honey Mustard, Thousand Island
Homemade Dressings: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Red Wine Vinaigrette, Creamy Champagne, Chunky Bleu Cheese, Buttermilk Ranch
Waldorf Chicken Salad
$17.95
Diced green apples, dried cranberries, walnuts, and grilled chicken served on top of a bed of mixed greens with raspberry vinaigrette
Uncle Tony
$17.95
Mixed greens, buttermilk signature fried chicken, tomato, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and red onions with homemade red wine vinaigrette
Pear and Goat Cheese Salad
$13.95
Mixed greens, diced pear, tangy goat cheese, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, and homemade creamy champagne vinaigrette
Soups
Creamy Tomato - Soup of the Day
$4.50/Cup
$7.50/Bowl
French Onion Crock
$7.50
Gimme More!
Add additional items to your meal!
Bacon
$5.95
Turkey Bacon
$5.95
Sausage
$3.95
Ham
$3.95
Hashbrowns
$3.50
Biscuits
$3.95
Toast
$3.50
White, whole wheat, multigrain, marble rye, or sourdough
GF Toast
$4.50
*One Egg
$1.75
French Fries
$4.50
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.50
Shoestring Onions
$5.50
Cheese Grits
$3.95/Cup
$4.95/Bowl
Cold Salad of the Day
$3.95
Chef's choice
Cup of Seasonal Fresh Fruit
$3.95
Side Salad
$6.95
Hollandaise
$1.75/Small
$4.50/Large
A Hearty Bowl of Oatmeal
$6.95
Made with cinnamon apples, cranberries, and walnuts
Corned beef hash
$7.95
Calves Menu $6.95
Children 12 & under
Sub cup of seasonal fresh fruit, green apple slices or carrot sticks for side item $1.00
Add above items to any meal for $2.00
Pancake
Served with bacon. Add toppings: strawberries, blueberries, or chocolate chips $1.00
French Toast
Our homemade French toast served with bacon
Scrambled Eggs
One scrambled egg served with bacon and toast
Chicken Fingers
Served with French fries
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Served with French fries
Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich
Served with French fries
Kids Burger*
Served with French fries. Add cheese $1.00
Tray Catering Prices
Half tray feeds 5-10 and will come with 1/2 pint of appropriate dipping sauce
Full tray feeds 10-15 and will come with 1 pint of appropriate dipping sauce
All prices are applicable to NYS sales fax
Rental of steam pans, racks, canned heat, and serving utensils available for additional charge. Please inquire for pricing
Pancakes*
$40.00/Half
$80.00/Full
French Toast*
$40.00/Half
$80.00/Full
French Toast Bites
$45.00/Half
$85.00/Full
Waffles
$40.00/Half
$80.00/Full
Scrambled Eggs*
$40.00/Half
$80.00/Full
Garden Salad*
$45.00/Half
$80.00/Full
Specialty Salads
$55.00/Half
$90.00/Full
Waldorf*, Uncle Tony, or Pear & Goat Cheese*
Add Grilled* or Fried Chicken to any Salad
$25.00/Half
$50.00/Full
Shrimp and Grits*
$75.00/Half
$125.00/Full
Fresh Homemade Biscuits
$24.00/One dozen
$48.00/Two dozen
Assorted Dinner Rolls
$20.00/Half
$40.00/Full
Seasonal Fruit Platter*
$45.00/Half
$80.00/Full
Bacon, Sausage, Ham, or Turkey Bacon*
$65.00/Half
$120.00/Full
Please choose one
Hashbrowns* or French Fries
$40.00/Half
$80.00/Full
Sweet Potato Fries or Shoestring Onions
$45.00/Half
$90.00/Full
Child Chicken Fingers
$45.00/Half
$70.00/Full
Buttermilk's Signature Fried Chicken
$65.00/Half
$120.00/Full
Grilled Chicken with Pico de Gallo*
$65.00/Half
$120.00/Full
Sliders
$65.00/Half
$120.00/Full
Choose one: Buttermilk's Chicken Sandwich, Fancy Pig*, Sweet Brie*, or The Roma*
Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
$55.00/Half
$100.00/Full
Choose one: Lumberjack*, OG*, BLT*, or The Kitchen Sink*
Homemade Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad*, or Coleslaw
$45.00/Half
$80.00/Full
Topping Bar
$75.00/One size
Pint of each: Straw, Blue, Rasp. 1/2 pint each: Nutella, PB Sauce, Chocolate Chips*
Buffet style service, 3 hour package
Includes soda, juice, coffee, tea
30 person minimum Mon - Thurs, 40 person minimum Fri - Sun
Space available beginning at 4:30 pm, $39.95
Bread Basket with Butter
Bread Basket with Butter
Assorted biscuit, buns, and rolls
Salad
Choice of one. Dressing served on the side.
Garden Salad
Balsamic vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
Chopped romaine, croutons, and shaved parmesan cheese
OR
Caprese Salad
$3.50/pp
Beautifully displayed sliced fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, fresh basil, balsamic vinaigrette
Pear and Goat Cheese
$3.50/pp
Crumbled goat cheese, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, and sliced pears rested atop mixed greens. Champagne vinaigrette
Egg Options
Fluffy Homemade Scrambled Eggs
OR
Buttermilk's Traitor Eggs Benedict
$4.00/pp
Grilled ham and a poached egg served atop one of our homemade buttermilk biscuits, topped with hollandaise sauce
Buttermilk's Gump Benedict
$6.00/pp
Sauteed cajun shrimp set atop halved croissants, topped with hollandaise sauce
Buttermilk's Signature Breakfast Items
Choose one from the following
Buttermilk's Homemade Pancakes
Belgian Waffles
Cinnamon Brioche French Toast
Breakfast Meats
Choose one from the following
Bacon
Ham
Sausage Links
Turkey Bacon
Side Items
Hash Browns and French Fries
OR
Substitute one choice for:
Sweet Potato Fries
$3.00/pp
With maple dipping sauce
Homemade Fried Shoestring Onions
$3.00/pp
Choose One Sandwich
The Lumberjack
Multigrain bread with yellow and white cheddar cheeses, sliced tomato, bacon, and avocado
The OG
White bread with American cheese, sliced tomato, and bacon
BLT
Brioche sliders with mixed greens, bacon, and sliced tomato. Mayonnaise served on the side
OR
Fancy Pig
$4.00/pp
Cinnamon brioche sliders with goat cheese, mascarpone, sauteed onions, fig jam, and BBQ pulled pork
Buttermilk's Signature Fried Chicken Sliders
$4.00/pp
Brioche sliders with buttermilk's signature fried chicken, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, and mixed greens. Homemade ranch dressing served on the side
The Roma
$4.00/pp
Ciabatta sliders with grilled chicken, fresh spinach, roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, garlic aioli, and fresh mozzarella
Grilled Chicken with Pico de Gallo
Grilled Chicken with Pico de Gallo
Fresh grilled chicken breast topped with homemade pico de gallo (diced tomatoes and red onion with cilantro, finely chopped jalapenos, and fresh lime juice). Served with homemade buttermilk ranch and chipotle mayo on the side
+$6.00 pp - Sliced grilled skirt steak instead of chicken
+$8.00 - Sauteed cajun shrimp instead of chicken
+$6.00 pp - Sliced grilled skirt steak instead of chicken
+$8.00 - Sauteed cajun shrimp instead of chicken
Chef's Choice Dessert Assortment
Chef's Choice Dessert Assortment
Delicious dessert display to compliment a gourmet tea and coffee service
Additions
Welcome Table
$6.00/pp
Assorted pastries, danish, and muffins
Fresh sweet iced tea, lemonade, and cucumber water
Lox platter - market price per pound
Capers, sliced tomatoes, sliced red onion, whipped cream cheese, and bagel assortment accompany smoked salmon
Fresh sweet iced tea, lemonade, and cucumber water
Lox platter - market price per pound
Capers, sliced tomatoes, sliced red onion, whipped cream cheese, and bagel assortment accompany smoked salmon
Topping Bar
$5.00/pp
Includes fresh sliced strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, chocolate chips, Nutella, peanut butter, and fresh whipped cream
Our most requested menu of the year! Our cozy fall menu is nuanced with all of your favorite fall spices.
Food Selections
Harvest Menu
Butternut Squash Soup
$4.50/Cup
$7.50/Bowl
Candied bacon garnish
Pumpkin Cheesecake Pancakes
$13.95/Short stack
$17.95/Full stack
Buttermilk’s Signature pancakes with real pumpkin, fall spices, cinnamon cream cheese drizzle, pumpkin cream cheese drizzle, and pecans. Full stack is served with choice of sausage, bacon, ham, or turkey bacon.
Harvest Benedict Skillet*
$19.95
Hot skillet of roasted sweet potato, red potatoes, butternut squash, carrots and brussel sprouts with a hint of fall spices. Topped with two poached eggs and hollandaise. Served with choice of toast or homemade buttermilk biscuit.
Apple Pie Stuffed French Toast
$17.95
Brioche French Toast stuffed with homemade cInnamon sugar baked apples, cinnamon cream cheese drizzle and pie crumble. Served with choice of sausage, bacon, ham, or turkey bacon
Beverage Selections
Harvest Beverages
Caramel Apple Mimosa
$13.95
Apple Cider, brut champagne, cinnamon sugar and caramel rim
Seasonal Beer
$9.00
Montauk Brewing Company Pumpkin with cinnamon sugar rim
Pumpkin Spice Latte
$7.95
Made with real pumpkin! Pie spices, caramel, espresso, steamed milk, cinnamon sugar rim
Pumpkin Pie Sweet Cream Cold Brew
$9.95
Sail Away cold brew coffee with pumpkin pie flavored sweet cream cold foam